Baking Instructions - The Original Cookie Lady 🍪

NOTICE:

Consuming raw or undercooked eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Home Baking Instructions

Oven Instructions

Please keep all Raw Dough stored below 45℉. If temperature reaches above 45℉ they may be unsafe to consume.
When ready, preheat oven at 350℉ and place on Sheet Pan with space between for spread. Cookies can be baked directly on the Parchment Paper the Dough is packaged in. Remove label before placing Parchment in oven.
Bake for 8 minutes if thawed. Allow an extra 1-4 minutes for cold or frozen Dough (check every 30-60 seconds until done).
Remove Sheet Pan from oven and allow Cookies to rest 1 minute before moving to Cooling Rack. Allow another minute to cool before eating.
ENJOY!

FAQ

What Do I Need To Bake These?

You don’t need much! You can use a convection oven, toaster oven, pizza baker – some people have even microwaved them (although we do not recommend this method). If you don’t have a sheet pan you can sit them inside any oven safe baking dish. The often come with Parchment Paper and can be baked right on top of that! Make sure you have some oven mitts and a spatula or turner to get them out! You can cool them on a rack if you have one, if not – no big!

Can I Eat The Dough Raw?

It is unsafe to consume products containing raw eggs, which is why we designed Edible Dough specifically for this purpose!

Can I Bake The Edible Dough?

We do not recommend baking the Edible Dough versions of our Cookies. While they will turn out okay, and some may not notice the difference, the modified ingredients changes the texture once baked and it falls below our high quality standards.

How Many Cookies Per Serving Are Right For Me?

Everyone’s different, so there’s no universal answer. If this is your first time trying an edible, it’s been a while, or you don’t have much tolerance, it’s always best to start with one bite. Wait 15-20 minutes, then see how you feel. It you feel ok, have another bite. I might take a while to feel the effects, so don’t make the mistake of scarfing down a bunch of Cookies before you can tell how you feel! Better to stop at one Cookie and have another in an hour or two than go past your limit!

Help! Me or Someone I Know Had Too Many Cookies! What Do I Do?!

First off – relax. Even if you had one too many Cookies, the experience won’t last too long. Hydration is important, so drink lots of water! Lemons, peppercorns, and pine nuts will also have a calming effect.

How Do I Join the Believer Program?

You can find instructions here!

Where Can I Find Original Cookie Lady Cookies?

Find a list of our Vending Locations and Retail Partners here!

Do You Cater?

We sure do! Find out about Party Trays here!